I'm sorry, but I don't remember what topic it was and I'm really not invested in the issue. I also believe that the damagelog is relied upon too much. If you miss something, you just don't take action unless someone recorded it. Regardless, ask BKU or look it up.
You brought it up: it's your job to prove it. Also, disregarding the damage log as sufficient evidence or a sufficient tool for admins is excessive. Under your rule servers would never be able to ban anyone because expecting players to record each and every round of their entire night is foolhardy.
Would it not be more feasable to perhaps have a list of the items the victim had with them before they died? Am I just missing something obvious about this?
No, what if he or she threw their weapon away before he or she died? Or what if he or she took the weapon off someone else's body?